Home› States› New York› Lake Ronkonkoma› Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop
Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop

Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop

466 Hawkins Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

antiquescollectiblesfamily-friendlyindoorparkingvaluevintagewednesday-sunday

Hours

friday12-7PM
mondayClosed
saturday12-5PM
sunday12-5PM
thursday12-5PM
tuesdayClosed
wednesday12-5PM

Contact & Details

+1 631-384-0301
Visit Website
Get Directions

Location

What People Are Saying

You never know what you will find in this store loaded with treasures, Their prices are very reasonable , and the Owner Jay and his Mother were incredibly sweet and kind
Pretty cool place for the treasure hunt some really different and nice fines. I'll be back again
Definitely hidden treasures.Has tons of stuff. Friendly, helpful Proprietor

About Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop

Located in Lake Ronkonkoma, Jay’s Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop is a quirky spot that invites you to go on a treasure hunt. With an eclectic mix of antiques and vintage items, you might stumble upon charming collectibles like globes and coffee grinders at reasonable prices. Many shoppers rave about the sweet demeanor of the owner, Jay, and his mother, who ensure a friendly shopping experience.

While the inventory is vast, some visitors noted that the space feels cluttered and can be a bit overwhelming. A few reviews mentioned that certain items seemed overpriced, leading to mixed feelings about value. However, numerous patrons have left with bags full of bargains, emphasizing that you never know what delightful surprises await you here.

Open Wednesday through Sunday, this shop offers a unique shopping experience for those who enjoy browsing through various knick-knacks. Parking is accessible, making it convenient for local shoppers or anyone passing through the area. Whether you’re looking for a unique gift or just want to explore, Jay’s Hidden Treasures is worth a visit for its variety and friendly vibe.

Common Questions About Jay's Hidden Treasures Flea Market & Gift Shop

What are Jay's Hidden Treasures' hours in Lake Ronkonkoma?
They're open Wednesday through Sunday, with extended hours on Friday (12–7PM) and shorter hours on other days (12–5PM). Closed Monday and Tuesday, so plan your visit accordingly.
What kind of stuff will I find there?
Expect an eclectic mix of antiques, vintage items, and collectibles—think globes, coffee grinders, and all sorts of knick-knacks. It's truly a treasure hunt vibe, so inventory varies and surprises are part of the fun.
Are the prices reasonable?
Most shoppers report reasonable, fair prices and come away with bargains. A few items may feel pricier than expected, but many visitors find great value overall.
Is there parking available?
Yes, parking is accessible at the location, making it convenient for local shoppers and visitors passing through the area.
What's the shopping experience like?
The owner Jay and his mother are known for being incredibly sweet, kind, and helpful. The space is packed with inventory, which some find exciting and others find a bit overwhelming—but that's part of the treasure-hunt charm.

Flea Market Day Kit

For shoppers and vendors alike. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Folding Wagon Haul your finds without breaking your back. Shop on Amazon → Money Belt Keep cash and cards close in a crowd. Shop on Amazon → Heavy-Duty Totes Reusable bags strong enough for the haul home. Shop on Amazon → Pop-Up Canopy Shade your booth and your goods in minutes. Shop on Amazon → Folding Table A sturdy surface to lay out what you are selling. Shop on Amazon → Jeweler's Loupe Inspect marks and condition before you pay. Shop on Amazon →

Is this your business?

Claim this listing to update your info, add photos, post deals, and connect with customers.

Claim This Listing